Towards Understanding How Readers Integrate Charts and Captions:
A Case Study with Line Charts

Dae Hyun Kim
Stanford University / Tableau Research

Vidya Setlur
Tableau Research

Maneesh Agrawala
Stanford University

To appear in CHI 2021

Abstract

Charts often contain visually prominent features that draw attention to aspects of the data and include text captions that emphasize aspects of the data. Through a crowdsourced study, we explore how readers gather takeaways when considering charts and captions together. We first ask participants to mark visually prominent regions in a set of line charts. We then generate text captions based on the prominent features and ask participants to report their takeaways after observing chart-caption pairs. We find that when both the chart and caption describe a high-prominence feature, readers treat the doubly emphasized high-prominence feature as the takeaway; when the caption describes a low-prominence chart feature, readers rely on the chart and report a higher-prominence feature as the takeaway. We also find that external information that provides context, helps further convey the caption’s message to the reader. We use these findings to provide guidelines for authoring effective chart-caption pairs.

Paper PDF (5.9MB)

Supplemental ZIP (3.0MB)